| Tuesday 21st September 2004 | ||||||
| Birmingham City (PREM) | 3 | Lincoln City (LGE2) | 1 | 14,400 | ||
| Burnley (CHMP) | 1 | Wolverhampton Wanderers (CHMP) | 1 | 5,013 | ||
| AET, Burnley win 4-2 on penalties | ||||||
| Colchester United (LGE1) | 2 | West Bromwich Albion (PREM) | 1 | 4,591 | ||
| AET | ||||||
| Crewe Alexandra (CHMP) | 3 | Sunderland (CHMP) | 3 | 3,804 | ||
| AET, Crewe win 4-2 on penalties | ||||||
| Crystal Palace (PREM) | 2 | Hartlepool United (LGE1) | 1 | 4,233 | ||
| AET | ||||||
| Doncaster Rovers (LGE1) | 2 | Ipswich Town (CHMP) | 0 | 6,020 | ||
| Grimsby Town (LGE2) | 0 | Charlton Athletic (PREM) | 2 | 5,735 | ||
| Leeds United (CHMP) | 1 | Swindon Town (LGE1) | 0 | 18,476 | ||
| Manchester City (PREM) | 7 | Barnsley (LGE1) | 1 | 19,578 | ||
| Milton Keynes Dons FC (LGE1) | 1 | Cardiff City (CHMP) | 4 | 2,266 | ||
| Norwich City (PREM) | 1 | Bristol Rovers (LGE2) | 0 | 18,658 | ||
| Reading (CHMP) | 0 | Watford (CHMP) | 3 | 8,429 | ||
| Tranmere Rovers (LGE1) | 0 | Portsmouth (PREM) | 1 | 6,966 | ||
| West Ham United (CHMP) | 3 | Notts. County (LGE2) | 2 | 11,111 | ||
| Wrexham (LGE1) | 2 | Sheffield United (CHMP) | 3 | 3,423 | ||
| Yeovil Town (LGE2) | 0 | Bolton Wanderers (PREM) | 2 | 8,047 | ||