Player Ratings v Newcastle Utd

Last updated : 04 October 2004 By Brian Cartlidge
Birmingham City 2 Newcastle United 2
03 October 2004 at 15:00
Player Ratings



Taylor
- Didn't have too much to do. Not at fault for either goals but was almost embarrassed by Robert's late free kick effort.

Melchiot - Didn't get forward as often as usual but still a steady performance once again.

Clapham - An adequate performance although may have done better with the header that led to Newcastle's equaliser.

Cunningham - Marshalled the defence well.

Upson - Good performance considering the opposition and a welcome first ever goal for the club.

Johnson - Worked tirelessly as always and put in some good crosses when going forward down the right flank.

Gronkjaer - A constant threat throughout. Worked hard. Possibly his best 90 minutes since joining the club?

Savage - An erratic first twenty minutes but when he settled put in his usual workman-like showing. Great dead-ball cross for Upsons goal and was unlucky not to score himself.

Izzet - Did a good man-to-man marking job on Bowyer before what looked a bad injury.

Dunn - Absolutely superb. Keep him fit and we'll be climbing up the table rapidly.

Heskey - Clearly not fit hence the nine minute appearance.

SUBS:

Clemence - Good performance in the middle of the park after his introduction. Took over where Izzet left-off.

Yorke - Held the line well, took his goal superbly and perhaps could have won it with a great shot on the turn late-on.

Gray - Cameo seven minutes appearance as a replacement for the tiring Dunn.


Blues
1 Taylor, Mai
3 Clapham
4 Cunningham
5 Upson
29 Melchiot
6 Izzet (Clemence 36)
10 Dunn (Gray 83)
7 Gronkjaer
8 Savage
22 Johnson
16 Heskey (Yorke 9)
Substitutes
12 Bennett
21 Gray (Dunn 83)
25 Clemence (Izzet 36)
33 Yorke (Heskey 9)
19 Morrison
10Goal Attempts6
6On Target3
4Off Target2
0Hit Woodwork1
5Offsides5
6Corners5
17Fouls14
Newcastle
1 Given
35 Bernard (Robert 64)
3 Elliott
5 O'Brien
2 Carr
4 Butt
29 Bowyer (Hughes 81)
7 Jenas
9 Shearer
10 Bellamy
11 Kluivert (Milner 46)
Substitutes
12 Harper
18 Hughes (Bowyer 81)
32 Robert (Bernard 64)
17 Ambrose
16 Milner (Kluivert 46)
Referee
H Webb, S Yorkshire
Attendance
29021
Birmingham C. Cards
Dunn53dissent
Clemence59unsporting behaviour
Savage90unsporting behaviour
Newcastle Utd. Cards
Elliott48unsporting behaviour
Butt73unsporting behaviour